/?pid=6033

Updated:04:35 PM EST Jan 10


this is ggmania.com subsite SSD versus Enterprise SAS and SATA disks - TechAmok

SSD versus Enterprise SAS and SATA disks - [hardware]
05:08 PM EDT - Mar,20 2009 - post a comment

AnandTech has published an article called 'SSD versus Enterprise SAS and SATA disks'.
The system administrators with high-end, ultra mission critical applications will still look down their nose at the Intel X25-E Extreme SLC drive: it is not dual ported (SATA interface) and it does not have a "super capacitor" to allow the controller to write its 16MB cache to the flash array in the event of a sudden power outage. For those people, the Enterprise Flash Drives (EFD) of EMC make sense with capacities up to 400GB but prices ten times as high as the Intel X25-E SLC drive.

For the rest of us, probably 90% of the market, the Intel X25-E is nothing short of amazing: it offers at least 3 to 13 times better OLTP performance at less than a tenth of the power consumption of the classical SAS drives. We frankly see no reason any more to buy SAS or FC drives for performance critical OLTP databases unless the database sizes are really huge. From the moment you are using lots of spindles and most of your hard disks are empty, Intel's SLC SSDs make a lot more sense.

However, be aware that these ultra fast storage devices cause bottlenecks higher in the storage hierarchy. The current storage processors seem to have to trouble scaling well from four to eight drives. We have witnessed negative scaling only in some extreme cases, 100% random writes in RAID 5 for example. It is unlikely that you will witness this kind of behavior in the real world. Still, the trend is clear: scaling will be poor if you attach 16 or more SLC SSDs on products like the Adaptec 51645, 51645, and especially the 52445. Those RAID controllers allow you to attach up to 24 drives, but the available storage processor is the same as our Adaptec 5805 (IOP348 at 1.2GHz). We think it is best to attach no more than eight SLC drives per IOP348, especially if you are planning to use the more processor intensive RAID levels like RAID 5 and 6. Intel and others had better come up with faster storage processors soon, because these fast SLC drives make the limits of the current generation of storage processors painfully clear.

Our testing also shows that choosing the "cheaper but more SATA spindles" strategy only makes sense for applications that perform mostly sequential accesses. Once random access comes into play, you need two to three times more SATA drives - and there are limits to how far you can improve performance by adding spindles. Finally, to get the best performance out of your transactional applications, RAID 10 is still king, especially with the Intel X25-E.


Add your comment (free registrationrequired)

Short overview of recent news articles

Jan,10 2026 Welcome to the Wasteland - Fallout (American TV series) fan video
Jan,09 2026 GOOD LUCK, HAVE FUN, DON'T DIE Trailer 2 (2026) Sam Rockwell
Jan,07 2026 NVIDIA Releases GeForce 591.74 WHQL Drivers with DLSS 4.5 Support
Jan,07 2026 Predator: Badlands Exclusive Deleted Scene (2025)
Jan,06 2026 Greenland 2: Migration - Official Trailer 3 (2026) Gerard Butler,
Jan,05 2026 The Best Laptops of 2025 - For Gaming, Creators & Students!
Jan,05 2026 Punkt Updates its Privacy-Focused Smartphone
Jan,05 2026 Clicks Launches New Ways to Add a Physical Keyboard to Your Life
Jan,05 2026 Building a PC for the First Time
Jan,03 2026 Building a PC in 2026
Jan,02 2026 I want this phone so bad... - Samsung Galaxy Z TriFold
Jan,02 2026 The Real Finewine Strikes Again: Ryzen 5600X, 5700X & 5800XT Revisit
Jan,02 2026 Nokia N8 Symbian Re-Awakened With Passion
Jan,02 2026 Europe Forces Apple to Open up More of iOS
Jan,02 2026 Must have Privacy and Security Tweaks: 2026 Edition
Jan,01 2026 How Did RAM Get So Expensive?!
Dec,31 2025 GeForce RTX 5090 prices to soar to $5,000 as NVIDIA and AMD prep GPU
Dec,30 2025 Hacker arrested for KMSAuto malware campaign with 2.8 million
Dec,29 2025 Killer Whale - Official Trailer (2026) Virginia Gardner, Mel
Dec,28 2025 NVIDIA Showed Me Their Supercomputer
Dec,28 2025 2026 CPU Launches! AMD, Intel & NVIDIA: Buy Now or Wait?
Dec,27 2025 Disable this Windows Feature that Secretly Eats Up RAM!
Dec,27 2025 New Windows 11 vs Old Malware: Will it survive?
Dec,27 2025 Samsung TriFold Durability Test: We found the limit
Dec,26 2025 TRUST WALLET CONFIRMS SECURITY BREACH
Dec,26 2025 Xiaomi 17 Ultra Leads And Samsung To Follow With A 10 Percent Price
Dec,25 2025 Merry Christmas Gaming Insanity
Dec,24 2025 Battlefield 6 - Official PS5 Features Trailer
Dec,24 2025 NVIDIA GeForce Hotfix Driver 591.67 Released
Dec,23 2025 Finally! A Battery That's Better Than Energizer and Duracell!
Dec,22 2025 NVIDIA Killing Cheap 16GB Local AI GPUs?
Dec,21 2025 Top 10 Movie Sequels of All Time
Dec,21 2025 He Built a Privacy Tool. Now He's Going to Prison (Kone Rodriguez,
Dec,20 2025 Insane Moves! B-Boy Shigekix vs. B-Boy Issin - Red Bull BC One World
Dec,20 2025 9800X3D & RTX 5070 Ti Gaming PC - MSI Project Zero Done Right
Dec,19 2025 The XG27AQWMG Sets a New Standard for 1440p OLED
Dec,19 2025 OnePlus 15R Boasts Huge 7,400 mAh Battery
Dec,19 2025 Motorola Refreshes moto g power for 2026
Dec,18 2025 NVIDIA GeForce 591.59 WHQL Driver
Dec,18 2025 Are We Quitting YouTube Due To DRAM Apocalypse?
>> News Archive <<

TechAmok - Privacy Policy        loading time:0.01secs