/?pid=3758

Updated:12:24 PM EST Dec 20


this is ggmania.com subsite RIAA Says Personal Copies Are 'Unauthorized' - TechAmok

RIAA Says Personal Copies Are 'Unauthorized' - [crime-law]
07:53 PM EST - Dec,11 2007 - (1 comments)

You are not going to believe this one. According to RIAA, those MP3 and AAC files that you've ripped from your CD collection are still "unauthorized copies" in the eyes of the recording industry. In a brief filed late last week, the RIAA said that the MP3 files on a PC owned by a file-sharing defendant who had admitted to ripping them himself were 'unauthorized copies.' Heh WTF!

Atlantic v. Howell is a bit unusual because the defendants, husband and wife Jeffrey and Pamela Howell, are defending themselves against the recording industry's lawsuit without the benefit of a lawyer. They were sued by the RIAA in August 2006 after an investigator from SafeNet discovered evidence of file-sharing over the KaZaA network.  The Howells have denied any copyright infringement on their part. In their response to the RIAA's lawsuit, they said that the MP3 files on their PC are and "always have been" for private use. "The files in question are for transfer to portable devices, that is legal for 'fair use,'" reads their response.

After several years of litigation and nearly 30,000 lawsuits, making a copy of a CD you bought for your own personal usage is still a concept that the recording industry is apparently uncomfortable with. During the Jammie Thomas trial this fall, the head of litigation from Sony BMG testified that she believed that ripping your own CDs is stealing.  When asked by the RIAA's lead counsel whether it was wrong for consumers to make copies of CDs they have purchased, Jennifer Pariser replied in the negative. "When an individual makes a copy of a song for himself, I suppose we can say he stole a song," said Pariser. Making "a copy" of a song you own is just "a nice way of saying 'steals just one copy'," according to Pariser.

last 10 comments:

(07:39 PM EST - Dec,12 2007) - devilhood
RIAA have only ever cared about money and have complete disregard for the consumer, so this comes to no surprise really.
If they ever try to bring someone down with the accusation of an "unauthorized copy", it will fall on deaf ears and cost them a stupendous amount of cash.
This is an iPod-era, a digital revolution; the RIAA can get stuffed.

Add your comment (free registrationrequired)

Short overview of recent news articles

Dec,20 2025 Insane Moves! B-Boy Shigekix vs. B-Boy Issin - Red Bull BC One World
Dec,20 2025 9800X3D & RTX 5070 Ti Gaming PC - MSI Project Zero Done Right
Dec,19 2025 The XG27AQWMG Sets a New Standard for 1440p OLED
Dec,19 2025 OnePlus 15R Boasts Huge 7,400 mAh Battery
Dec,19 2025 Motorola Refreshes moto g power for 2026
Dec,18 2025 NVIDIA GeForce 591.59 WHQL Driver
Dec,18 2025 Are We Quitting YouTube Due To DRAM Apocalypse?
Dec,16 2025 The Samsung TriFold is AWESOME!
Dec,16 2025 $30 vs $30,000 TV
Dec,16 2025 Stranger Things 5 - Volume 2 Trailer
Dec,14 2025 Google Brings Live Video Sharing to 911 Calls on Android
Dec,14 2025 Samsung One UI 8.5 Will Offer New Features
Dec,14 2025 Dell AW3225QF Review - 32-inch curved gaming monitor
Dec,13 2025 HW News - AMD Says AI Definitely, Absolutely Not A Bubble, New
Dec,13 2025 The BEST Smartphones of 2025!
Dec,11 2025 10 Atmospheric Games That Might CHANGE YOUR LIFE
Dec,11 2025 Samsung Galaxy S26 Ultra - Samsung Isn't Hiding It Anymore
Dec,10 2025 AMD Releases Adrenalin Edition 25.12.1 WHQL Drivers
Dec,10 2025 S25 Ultra VS 17 Pro Max
Dec,09 2025 All You Need Is Kill - Official Trailer
Dec,09 2025 Why can’t you be NORMAL?!? Roasting Staff Setups
Dec,09 2025 A Ryzen Cooling MONSTER - be quiet Silent Loop 3 Review
Dec,07 2025 The Boys - Official Final Season Trailer
Dec,06 2025 Unemployed in your 30's
Dec,05 2025 Play Store Customers to Receive Automatic Payments from $700 Million
Dec,05 2025 Google's Second Release of Android 16 Brings Smart Notifications
Dec,05 2025 Netflix To Buy Warner Bros for $82.7 Billion
Dec,03 2025 Micron to Exit Crucial Consumer Business, Ending Retail SSD and DRAM
Dec,02 2025 Samsung Galaxy Z TriFold Unboxing!
Nov,30 2025 Top 5 Best CPUs of 2025
Nov,30 2025 Google Adding AirDrop to Android
Nov,29 2025 20 TOP ALIEXPRESS products for BLACK FRIDAY
Nov,26 2025 Stop Wasting Money on Premium Monitors
Nov,23 2025 The Blackest Friday - Tech News Nov 23
Nov,23 2025 T-Roc: Will this new VW be the best car of 2026?
Nov,23 2025 Can I build my own Steam Machine?
Nov,22 2025 50 NEXT-LEVEL Gadgets Every Man NEEDS to See
Nov,22 2025 RETURN TO SILENT HILL Trailer (2026)
Nov,20 2025 I was WRONG about the Porsche 911 GT3 (or was I?)
Nov,20 2025 Pi GPT Tool Turns Raspberry Pi into a ChatGPT-Powered Smart Device
>> News Archive <<

TechAmok - Privacy Policy        loading time:0.01secs