this is ggmania.com subsite
|
Eight Video Card Coolers Tested and Compared - TechAmok
Eight Video Card Coolers Tested and Compared - [hardware] 04:23 AM EDT - Jul,19 2007 - post a comment
MadShrimps
tested and compared 8 different VGA coolers from Zalman, Gigabyte, Vantec,
Coolermaster, ZEROTherm, Arctic Cooling and Titan. The models range from
completely passive no-noise solutions to multi heat pipes equipped cooling
monsters. Here's an excerpt:
Let's analyze the data gathered, the stock NVIDIA cooling does a poor job at
keeping the 7900 GT running cool, at 75�C it's running hot and at 60+dBA it's
very loud too. The only other cooling solution which surpasses the stock cooling
in the noise department is at the other end of the performance chart.
- Gigabyte V-Power: this 7900 GTX cooler look-a-like does a formidable
job at cooling the 7900 GT, although at high speed the fan is quite noticeable,
but performance is really good, only 47�C (amazing 28�C drop compared to stock)
and ~52dBA. Reducing the fan speed makes the cooler silent, but you do get a
+7�C temperature penalty.
- Vantec IceberQ 6: the design of the IceberQ 6 is quite dated and it
shows in the chart, at high fan speed the GPU is kept cool enough (-20�C) at
55�C, the fan is noticeable at ~51dBA. If we want silence, the low fan setting
delivers, but temperature rises by 13�C!
- Coolermaster CoolViva Z1: The CoolViva Z1 in complete passive mode
performs on par with the stock NVIDIA cooling, minus the noise of course. A
commendable effort, but not much room left for overclocking. If we speed up the
rear case fan a bit noise increases only ~3dBA but temperature drops to a more
comfortable level at 67�C. But it's better to mount a silent fan on the Z1, with
a silent 80mm the noise level is practically the same as with the speedier rear
fan, but temperatures are now at ~55�C mark! Setting the 80mm fan speed to high
puts the Z1 into the higher performance part of the chart, the noise level is
now ~51dBA and it's definitely noticeable, but temperatures drop another 6�C to
~49�C.
- Coolermaster CoolViva Pro: The fan of the Pro was only tested at one
setting: full speed, because of compatibility issue connecting to a normal 3-pin
fan speed controller. The Pro is noisy at full speed, at 53dBA is noticeable,
temperature results are mediocre at best, 2�C hotter than the quieter CoolViva
Z1. We suspect that mounting pressure is the issue here.
- Arctic Cooling Accelero S1: The S1 doesn't fail to impress, no matter
how you look at it. The performance in complete passive mode is stunning, 56�C!
Increasing rear case fan speed to 7v drops temperatures 6�C to 50�C under load.
But as before, it's better to provide direct airflow to the S1, with the Turbo
Module installed and running at low speed the noise level is at 42dBA,
temperatures are at an amazing low of 44.5�C. Increasing the Turbo Module speed
to high increases noise to 46.7dBA making it faintly audible, but the expected
performance increase is absent, only -1�C. We suggest Arctic Cooling lowers the
default speed of the Turbo Module when running at full speed, the extra airflow
doesn't pay of. As a last test we mounted the 120mm 2900rpm fan and were not
disappointed by the thermal performance of the S1, at 41.5�C this 7900 GT was
running 33.5�C cooler! (at 73.7dBA it was also audible from two houses down the
street, but who wants silence anyway, right? ;-) )
- ZEROTherm GX815: The biggest competitor of the GX815 when comparing
design is the VF900 from Zalman, we can see from the results, that at high speed
the newer GX815 falls between the VF900 running at high/low speed. We did not
disable the temperature control of the fan, so depending on your ambient
temperature and VGA card used the noise levels will differ. At 50.3dBA the GX815
was well audible; when we lowered the max voltage of the fan to 5v the GX815
become very quiet, performance was still ok at 54.5�C, but it's bested by the
performance/noise ratio of the VF900 (@low).
- Titan Twin Turbo: The Twin Turbo had quite a bit of high end
competitors in this roundup, but it managed to perform respectfully, build for
high airflow the TT does best with its fan running at full speed, generating
~48dBA it's noticeable but not too disturbing. Performance trails the V-Power
unit from Gigabyte by only 0.5�C, negligible. At low setting the TT bests the
V-Power in both noise and temperature results, and does quiet well in the
overall ranking.
|
|
Add your comment (free registrationrequired)
Short overview of recent news articles |
Jun,11 2025 WWDC 2025: Everything Revealed in 9 Minutes Jun,10 2025 Microsoft June 2025 Patch Tuesday fixes exploited zero-day, 66 flaws Jun,10 2025 This Malware BREAKS WINDOWS! Jun,10 2025 Reset Forgotten Password without Any Software, without USB drive in Jun,08 2025 Microsoft Will Block Unsupported Hardware For Windows 11 Jun,08 2025 Memory Wars! Apple vs Ryzen - Is Unified Memory Faster than Shared Jun,06 2025 Predator: Killer of Killers - Exclusive Clip (2025) Jun,06 2025 Enable Deep Effect on Samsung One Ui 7 Jun,05 2025 Google Kills Off PayPal in Google Wallet Jun,05 2025 Samsung's Next Flagship Foldable Will be Ultra Jun,05 2025 Over 40 Malicious Chrome Extensions Mimic Popular Brands to Steal Jun,03 2025 The Witcher IV - Unreal Engine 5 tech demo Jun,02 2025 Nintendo Switch 2 Welcome Tour trailer Jun,01 2025 Stranger Things 5 | Date Announcement | Netflix May,31 2025 RTX 5060 Review... No wonder NVIDIA tried to stop us from talking May,30 2025 Samsung Galaxy Watch 8 Classic Is Here - 7 New Updates May,30 2025 Biggest Windows 11 24H2 May Update in the Main Release May,29 2025 How Much Money Should You Spend on a Gaming PC? May,29 2025 laud Note vs Note Pin - Which AI Voice Recorder To Choose May,29 2025 Samsung One UI 8.0 vs One UI 7.0 - 25+ Changes May,28 2025 SECRET CODE UPDATE for Samsung Galaxy Phone to Boost Performance & May,27 2025 WhatsApp is finally available on iPad May,27 2025 Simple Trick To Lower CPU Temperatures May,26 2025 Alma & The Wolf - Official Trailer (2025) Ethan Embry, Li Jun Li, May,25 2025 Change These Browser Security Settings NOW May,24 2025 I NEED AMD to Seize This Moment - RX 9060XT May,23 2025 Windows 98 with a G41 Core 2 Duo System May,23 2025 Disable These Windows Settings for Better FPS! May,20 2025 I Got the Golden GPU from Dubai May,19 2025 Windows 10 emergency update KB5061768 fixes BitLocker boot loops - May,19 2025 2025 AUDI S5 AVANT // 0-100 100-200 TOP SPEED POV & SOUND May,18 2025 Jurassic World Rebirth - Official 'Alert' Teaser Trailer (2025) May,18 2025 F1 25 and F1 The Movie hand in hand May,17 2025 Everyone is Cooling Their PC Wrong May,16 2025 M5 KILLER? Testing the MERCEDES E63S AMG! May,16 2025 Samsung Fully Reveals 5.8mm-Thick Galaxy S25 Edge May,16 2025 Apple Intros New Accessibility Apps, Plus Accessibility "Labels" May,16 2025 Americana - Official Trailer (2025) Sydney Sweeney, Halsey, Simon May,16 2025 Aston Martin x Apple CarPlay Ultra - Next generation of automotive May,15 2025 Google TAG deleted 23,000+ YouTube channels in January, February,
>> News Archive <<
| |
|